Don’t Conflate Demonstrators with Rioters: Legitimate Protest Is More Important than Ever

The images from Hamburg are horrifying: Black masked radicals depredation a city’s streets, environment cars on glow indiscriminately, destroying all in their trail in a blind fit of rage. Building barricades and defending themselves with paving stones and other objects for battles opposite police. They have, it would seem, usually one idea in mind: violence.

The state contingency do whatever is required to stop these people — even if it means promulgation in heavily armed special military units as happened on Friday night in a Schanzenviertel neighborhood.

Photo Gallery:
A Hamburg Neighborhood Digs Out

But what a state contingency equivocate doing during all costs is mistaking a aroused troublemakers with those who are perfectionist a concrete discuss about a issues during hand. Political celebration member contingency also be clever to equivocate extended generalizations. The rioters might scream domestic slogans as they go about their mortal business, though they aren’t political. At a most, they censor among and behind those for whom politics is a priority.

That is what creates it so formidable to heed and compute among a several groups — both politically and on a travel level. Police in Hamburg are experiencing as most this weekend. Everyone who wants to criticism peacefully opposite a G-20 should, of course, do so — even on this Saturday after a tear of assault final night. Claims that all those holding to a streets in antithesis to a limit are display support for a assault of a black-clad host are passed wrong.

It is totally legitimate to criticism in Hamburg opposite a dim side of globalization, opposite a climate-damaging policies of many G-20 countries or some-more broadly opposite a summit’s format. Doing so does not put such legitimate protesters in a same stay as those who are usually meddlesome in violence. Whether doing so is potentially dangerous following a assault of a past dual days is a apart doubt entirely.

International Newsletter

Sign adult for a newsletter — and get a really best of SPIEGEL in English sent to your email inbox twice weekly.

Peaceful criticism contingency be some-more than only a slogan. Those who find a participation of military officers during demonstrations to be a irritation should rethink their attitudes to a state. The state accords a adults many freedoms and rights. And a state is also in assign of guaranteeing sequence and control. Those who have a problem with that should design no sympathy.

Article source: http://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/g-20-violence-protest-is-more-important-than-ever-a-1156773.html#ref=rss