Philippines: Artificial white sandy beach could spell eco disaster
A stretch of coastline in the Philippine capital Manila has received backlash from environmentalists. The heavily polluted Manila Bay area, which had been slated for cleanup, has become the site of a controversial 500-meter stretch of white sand beach.
The beach, however, is anything but clean, environmentalists say.
“It’s an illusion,” said Lia Mai Torres, Executive Director of the Center for Environmental Concerns Philippines. “Just because it’s white it doesn’t mean it’s clean.”
The white sand is actually crushed dolomite sourced from a mine in Cebu in the central Philippines.
Using sand made from dolomite rock in such a project is highly uncommon, experts say. The large majority of sand beaches worldwide are made up of quartz and feldspar, whiledolomite sand is commonly used in road construction.
“I have never come across any beach nourishment with dolomite sand,” said Arnaud Vander Velpen who’s the monitoring and innovation lead in UNEP/GRID-Geneva’s Department on Sand Monitoring and Governance.
Sand makeup crucial for ecosystems
While UNEP/GRID-Geneva generally supports finding alternative sources of sand so as not to disrupt ecosystems in rivers and oceans when extracting them, Vander Velpen stressed it was vital to use sand which closely matches the makeup of the native sand to protect beach fauna.
“If you change the core characteristics of the native sand, the original sand, you need to do an environmental impact assessment (EIA) to find out how it’s going to impact the ecosystem and nearby ecosystems,” he told DW.
But according to Torres, such an assessment was not done in Manila.
Dolomite sand was dumped on the shores of Manila Bay — this photo shows what the bay looked like in September…
… and once the stretch was opened to the public
Beautification stunt instead of proper cleanup?
Manila Bay’s waters are heavily polluted by oil and trash from nearby residential areas and ports. A huge no swimming sign warns visitors to stay away from the ocean.
The Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) denies dolomite sand poses any risk to human health and the ecosystem.
However, scientists of the University of the Philippines have come forward disputing the DENR’s claims. A statement by the Institute of Biology said that using crushed dolomite did not address any of the rehabilitation phases and instead was “even more detrimental to the existing biodiversity as well as the communities in the area,” pointing to the case of waterbirds. “The dumping of dolomite in Manila Bay has effectively covered part of the intertidal area used by the birds thereby reducing their habitat.”
At peak migration season, Manila Bay is home to 90 waterbird species, including species of international conservation concern that are facing a very high extinction risk in the wild.
Authorities should focus on protecting and conserving biodiversity, they added. “Rehabilitating mangroves is an example of a nature-based solution that is cheaper and more cost-effective than the dolomite dumping project,” the scientists said.
Sand made from dolomite rock…
…is usually used in construction and not in beach nourishment
Moreover, the Marine Science Institute warned prolonged inhalation of finer dust particles of dolomite could “cause chronic health effects,” leading discomfort in the chest, shortness of breath and coughing.
They also warned dolomite sand grains would erode during storms and be carried out to sea, essentially being washed away.
Rehabilitation vs. reclamation
Environmentalists say covering up the beach doesn’t address the real issues of the bay. Torres and others believe the best way to clean up Manila Bay was not to add anything, but rather remove trash and pollution.
“There have been studies saying much of the waste comes from already collected waste — so these are open dump sites along the coast that get washed up because of the rain,” Torres said.
She criticized the authorities for continuing to push reclamation projects she says are at odds with each other. These projects will affect large areas of mangrove forests, she said – and experts warn that this, in turn, exacerbates coastal erosion.
“If you’ve removed the areas that helped trap the sand, like mangrove forests, then the likelihood increases that you will have to nourish a beach. Same as building right up to the waterfront,” UNEP/GRID-Geneva’s Vander Velpen said.
Plenty of sand in the sea?
The question of Manila’s contentious white beach echoes larger questions about sand mining worldwide. Global sand consumption has tripled over the past two decades, UNEP/GRID-Geneva has found. A huge chunk of it is now taken up by construction.
“Many operate on the assumption that natural sand is endless in its supply,” Vander Velpen said.
Global sand consumption has tripled in the past two decades
Sand scarcity is a concern shared by Stefan Schimmels of Forschungszentrum Küste who’s done extensive research on shore nourishment to stop coastal erosion. And as climate change and rising sea levels are threatening coasts, demand for sand will grow even more.
A large study looked at Strategies and Tools for Environment-Friendly Shore Nourishments as Climate Change Impact Low-Regret Measures (STENCIL project) with a focus on the German island of Sylt, a popular vacation spot.
About one million cubic meter of sand per year is used to maintain the coastal area of Sylt, STENCIL project head Schimmels said. That’s about 100 million 10-liter buckets of sand.
When sand was extracted off the coast of Sylt, underwater craters were formed. “You can still detect these craters even decades later,” Schimmels told DW.
“Also when you add a couple of meters sand onto the beach – you essentially bury all things that do creep and fly. How quickly will they recover?” He said more research was needed as there was still too little known about long-term effects on the environment.
Criticism piling up
As for Manila’s artificial white sand, it looks like some of it might have already blown away by a recent storm. DENR claims it was not washed away, but greyish sand, stones and other materials simply piled up over the dolomite sand. People in Manila tweeted photos that showed how the storm had ravaged the beach.
The authorities have been called tone-deaf for spending around 389 million pesos ($8 million; €6.8 million) on a beach nourishment project in the middle of a raging pandemic.
An image of cake iced with the words “It really hurts – that’s [worth] 389 million pesos?” has since gone viral.
“It’s just a waste of precious resources,” Torres said.
The environmental activist now also worries that she might be labeled a terrorist for speaking out under the Philippines’ controversial new anti-terrorism law. She says she could be arrested for inciting fear when talking about environmental dangers.
-
Sinking islands battle tides of climate change
Paradise lost
Small island nations around the world are already feeling the impact of rising sea levels. And probably none more so than the Maldives in the Indian Ocean, which is considered the lowest-elevation country on the planet. The average elevation of its 26 atolls is just 1.5 meters (5 feet) above sea level – so it wouldn’t take much for the country to be rendered completely uninhabitable.
-
Sinking islands battle tides of climate change
Underwater property
Rising waters have already caused some islanders to flee their homes for higher ground. On the Kiribati islands in the Pacific, some villages have been completely flooded. Local farmers also have to worry about encroachment of saltwater on their crops. The ever-approaching sea means less surface area for agriculture, and a greater need to transport food from afar.
-
Sinking islands battle tides of climate change
Temporary escape
Around 113,000 people call the Kiribati islands home. Locals who’ve been displaced often end up on the main island of South Tarawa, which has a sea wall to protect low-lying properties on the shore from rising waters – but that’s no permanent solution.
-
Sinking islands battle tides of climate change
Keeping the ocean at bay
The Dutch are famous for their efforts to fend off the sea – they built their first dikes to protect land from flooding more than 1,000 years ago. Today, a sophisticated system of dams and dikes allows two-thirds of the population live below sea level. Nevertheless, rising ocean levels are still a concern in the Netherlands, where there are future plans to fortify levees and build surge barriers.
-
Sinking islands battle tides of climate change
Sinking world heritage
Venice in northeastern Italy is no stranger to flooding – and according to experts, the iconic city will continue to sink. The Italian government has invested 9.6 billion euros ($7 billion) in the “Moses” water barrier project, designed to protect the city – a UNESCO World Heritage site – from rising oceans and high tides. The barriers are expected to be completed by 2016.
-
Sinking islands battle tides of climate change
Crisis in the Caribbean
Many small islands in far-flung corners of the ocean don’t have the money to fund large-scale climate change mitigation. And often, they’re not just facing rising seas – they’re also under threat from increasingly frequent cyclones and hurricanes. In the Caribbean islands of St. Lucia and Dominica, frequent storms wreak havoc on local agriculture, including bananas and avocados.
-
Sinking islands battle tides of climate change
More severe storms
The devastation caused by Typhoon Haiyan in the Philippines last November is a clear example of how the unpredictability of climate change can make weather events more severe for islands. Many homes in the typhoon’s path weren’t built to withstand typhoons, which previously tended to strike the north of the country. More than 6,200 people were killed.
-
Sinking islands battle tides of climate change
Paying for prosperity
Some argue that poorer, less-developed countries are now suffering as a consequence of Western industrialization. At the recent climate conference in Warsaw, Philippines Commissioner Yeb Saño made a passionate plea for action, saying: “What my country is going through as a result of this extreme climate event is madness.”
-
Sinking islands battle tides of climate change
Floating in the floodwaters
Although Bangladesh is on the mainland of Asia, it faces a huge risk from climate change due to its low-lying geography and population density. A mere 1-meter (3-foot) rise in sea level would cause half the country to be under water. Communities have started adapting to increased flooding by using floating agricultural technology to grow their crops.
-
Sinking islands battle tides of climate change
A new brand of refugee
There are fears sea level rises could eventually displace entire populations, creating hoards of climate change refugees. One idea floated by President Anote Tong of Kiribati some years ago was the possibility of building artificial islands for displaced locals to live on. Dubai – with its artificial island projects, like the one pictured here – may be able to help by sharing its experience.
Article source: https://www.dw.com/en/philippines-artificial-white-sandy-beach-could-spell-eco-disaster/a-55397340?maca=en-rss-en-all-1573-rdf