Karl Cramm will never forget the day in June 2019 when he received the kind of message he never expected to be confronted with. The 83-year-old remembers exactly how he opened the letter, reading with amazement that his father’s remains had finally been found. The letter had been sent by the German Federal Archives, which assists families in discovering the fates of the missing.
Seventy-six years had passed since his father, a soldier in the Wehrmacht, disappeared in the Russian city of Stalingrad, today called Volgograd. “When I last saw him, I was five years old,” Cramm says.
His father’s last letter from the front came in January 1943, arriving in the village of Gross Lafferde, near the western city of Braunschweig where most of the family still lives. After that, the letters that his mother sent 3,000 kilometers (1,864 miles) away to Stalingrad were returned unread.
“Our grief was profound,” he says.
Thereafter, there was no sign of his father, who was drafted by the army in 1939 and sent directly to the front. In 1942, the young corporal received his marching orders toward Russia. Stalingrad, which had been attacked and then besieged by the Wehrmacht in the winter of 1942-43, is well-known for being the location of one of the most brutal and costly battles in terms of casualties of any World War II campaigns.
Read more: May 8, 1945: Total defeat or day of liberation?
Russia celebrated the 75th anniversary of the defense of Stalingrad on Friday with somber memorials and patriotic military parades. Russian President Vladimir Putin was a highly visible presence throughout the day, laying wreaths, addressing veterans and attending military parades. He is seen here in front of 85-meter The Motherland Calls statue in what is now called Volgograd.
Putin told veterans the Soviet victory at Stalingrad was an inspiration. “The unified resistance and readiness for self-sacrifice were truly undefeatable, incomprehensible and frightening for the enemy,” Putin said. “Defenders of Stalingrad have passed a great heritage to us: love for the motherland, readiness to protect its interests and independence, to stand strong in the face of any test.”
Official figures said 30,000 spectators watched a military parade through the streets of Volgograd despite sub-zero temperatures. The parade included about 1,500 troops, armored vehicles and jets flying ahead.
The parade featured 75 tanks — one for each year since the victory — as well as an Iskander ballistic missile system and an advanced S-400 surface-to-air missile system. Ground forces included T-90 tanks and armored Tigr infantry mobility vehicles.
The memorial parade included people (traffic controllers according to some sources) dressed up in Red Army winter uniforms and felt boots. The Soviet Union’s defeat of the Nazis forms a pillar of modern Russian identity and has been increasingly celebrated by Moscow to stoke patriotism. Putin will almost certainly be reelected in presidential elections in two months.
Other displays of communist nostalgia included members of the Yunarmiya (Young Army) military patriotic movement as well as soldiers parading with images of Soviet war heroes and Soviet-style banners.
The battle of Stalingrad started in July 1942 and lasted five months and was the bloodiest battle in history. About 2 million soldiers and civilians perished in the fighting there, many from starvation and exposure. The final group of Nazi troops under Marshal Friedrich Paulus finally surrendered on February 2, 1943, in the first surrender by the Nazis since the war began.
Childhood without a father
In the years after the war, he felt his father’s absence very strongly, explains Cramm.
“I was so sad when I would see other children with their fathers, knowing mine would never come back,” he says, adding that he had to help with the harvest so that his family could afford everything he needed for school.
“When other children were out playing, I was working in the field with my mother.”
Later, after getting a job as a commercial clerk, he started a family of his own. But he always hoped he would find something out about his long-lost father. He sought the help of the German War Graves Commission (“Volksbund Deutsche Kriegsgräberfürsorge”), which tends the graves of soldiers killed during the war and searches for the remains of the missing. The commission estimates that 1.3 million German soldiers were never found.
Read more: Opinion: May 1945 — The start of a cold peace
But all Cramm’s research was in vain — until a letter arrived last summer from the Federal Archives.
“At first, I simply could not believe it, that any news had come at all,” explains the 83-year-old. “I was of course dumbfounded and began to cry.”
Karl Cramm shows a photo of his father at the Rossoschka German War Cemetery
Found during construction
His father’s bones were found on a construction site in Volgograd. They were part of a mass grave of more than 1,800 German soldiers.
For Cramm, the discovery was almost miraculous. “My joy was incredible,” he says. There is no way to know exactly when and how he died, “but I am happy that I know where he has been laid to rest.”
Identification tag was intact
That the fallen man in a mass grave in Volgograd was ever identified as Cramm’s father is thanks to the identification tag that was found with his remains. Every Wehrmacht soldier had to carry such a marker with them, expressly for the purpose of identifying them in the event of their death. However, in many cases, after so many decades buried underground, these markers can be too damaged to read or have disappeared entirely.
But in this case, the oval piece of metal was still there — somewhat weathered, but luckily, legible. However, the marker still had to be decoded. His name was not written on it, just his identification number.
Karl Cramm’s father’s ID tag held the key to identifying his remains, even 76 years later.
Returning names to the dead
The marker was then sent to the archives in Berlin, the only place where it could be decoded. There, specialists like historian Robert Balsam track down the names to which the numbers were assigned. For his research he must draw on a treasure unique to the archive: a comprehensive file of every single German soldier who fought in World War II, from private to general.
“There are more than 18.5 million name cards here,” explains Balsam, pointing to all the gray file boxes sitting on his shelves.
The card index was created during the war and gradually added to. Each card contains personal and military information on a soldier, including the identification number. For the missing, a relative’s address is also included.
“There are still many people who are searching, and for whom this is a part of their life,” the historian says.
Cramm, alongside his son who accompanied him on a trip to Russia, pay their respects at a funeral ceremony.
Some 1,200 identified every year
The chances of a soldier’s fate being unearthed after 75 years are not actually that slim. Remains are constantly found during construction projects, excavations, exhumations, and in former battle fields.
“Every year, about 1,200 soldiers classified as missing are identified here,” Balsam says. For him, every single identification is a “completely special moment,” because then a family gets not only knowledge of their relative, they have a place to lay flowers and find closure.
Only after such an identification, says Balsam, is it possible for many to say, “Now it is finished for me, now I know where he is.”
“A part of him”
It was just like this for Cramm. After receiving the letter from the Federal Archives, he made his way to Russia. He traveled to Volgograd with his son, where his father’s remains were buried at Rossoschka German War Cemetery. He took part in the funeral ceremony, laying a bouquet of white lilies and a photo of his father on the grave. He also brought flowers to the memorial for the Soviet soldiers, as a sign of reconciliation.
“The most important thing for me was that I could take his identification marker with me after that,” he explains. “He carried it from the beginning of the war to the end, so it is a part of him.”
The marker is now in the 83-year-old’s bedroom, where he can see it every day. “For me, it’s like my father has come back.”