Court: Muslim boy must attend NRW school’s Catholic service

A newly published decision from March, reveals that Germany’s Constitutional Court rejected a lawsuit by Muslim parents who wanted their son to be exempt from the religious teachings at a publicly funded Catholic school in the state of North Rhine-Westphalia. According to the court, the parents had not sufficiently made a constitutional case for why judges should consider the decision.

Underlining Germany’s sometimes porous boundary between church and state, the court has effectively affirmed the elementary school’s right to force non-Catholic students to attend religion classes and services.

The director of the school, which was not named in the ruling, told the parents that non-Catholic children could only attend the school if they signed a declaration confirming that their son would take part in religion classes and the school’s church services.

The Muslim family, identified in the ruling only by the initial S, lived just 150 meters (500 feet) from the school. The nearest nonconfessional school is 3.3 kilometers (2 miles) away.

Read more:

– Could Germany soon have a Muslim holiday?

– Islam in Germany: Muslims prefer to be talked to rather than talked about

– Is Islam changing Germany?

  • Deutschkurs für Asylbewerber (picture-alliance/dpa)

    Muslims in Europe: Integrated or not?

    How successful is linguistic integration?

    Three quarters of German-born Muslims grow up with German as a first language. Among immigrants, only one fifth claim that German is their first language. The trend of language skills improving with successive generations is apparent across Europe. In Germany 46 percent of all Muslims say that their national language is their first language. In Austria this is 37 percent, Switzerland 34 percent.

  • Afrika Kuss und Küsse (imago/Westend61)

    Muslims in Europe: Integrated or not?

    How do Muslims view interreligious relationships?

    According to a 2017 study by Religion Monitor, 87 percent of Swiss Muslims have frequent contact with non-Muslims in their free time. In Germany and France it is 78 percent, while in the UK it’s 68 percent and Austria, 62 percent. A large majority of Muslims in succeeding generations are found to have constant contact with non-Muslims, despite existing societal hurdles.

  • Österreich Muslimische Freiwillige Helfer für Flüchtlinge (picture-alliance/dpa/H. Neubauer)

    Muslims in Europe: Integrated or not?

    Do Muslims feel connected in Europe?

    Ninety-six percent of French Muslims feel connected with their country. The percentage of Muslims feeling the same way is equally high in Germany, while Switzerland has the highest levels, at 98 percent. Yet despite its relatively longer history of institutional openness to religious and cultural diversity, fewer Muslims, (89 percent) report feeling close ties to the UK.

  • Symbolbild Frauen Islam Kopftuch Migranten in Europa (picture-alliance/dpa/F. Dean)

    Muslims in Europe: Integrated or not?

    How important is religion in the daily life of European Muslims?

    Muslims from immigrant families maintain a strong religious commitment which continues across generations. Sixty-four percent of Muslims living in the UK describe themselves as highly religious. The share of devout Muslims stands at 42 percent in Austria, 39 percent in Germany, 33 percent in France and 26 percent in Switzerland.

  • Deutschland Muslime Integration (picture-alliance/dpa/O. Berg)

    Muslims in Europe: Integrated or not?

    What percentage of Muslim students pursue a degree?

    According to data, 36 percent of German-born Muslims finish their education by the age of 17, without pursuing further studies. In Austria too, this proportion is around 39 percent. On the other hand, owing to a more equitable school system in France, Muslims there register significantly better educational outcomes. Only one in ten Muslim students leaves school before reaching 17.

  • Asklepios Kinderklinik Sankt Augustin Ärztin mit Kopftuch Hijab (picture alliance/dpa/U.Baumgarten)

    Muslims in Europe: Integrated or not?

    What percentage of Muslims are in the job market?

    About 60 percent of all Muslims who moved to Germany before 2010 now hold a full-time job, while 20 percent work part-time jobs. The figures are similar to those of non-Muslims. Muslims in Germany had higher employment rates than in other European countries. In France, the unemployment rate among Muslims is 14 percent, far higher than the 8 percent reported for non-Muslims.

  • Minarette und Moscheen in Deutschland und Europa, Moschee Duisburg Flash-Galerie (AP)

    Muslims in Europe: Integrated or not?

    How widespread is the rejection of Islam?

    More than one in four non-Muslims in Austria do not want Muslims neighbors. This percentage is remarkably high in the UK as well, at 21 percent. In Germany, 19 percent of non-Muslim respondents say that they would not welcome Muslim neighbors. The figure stands at 17 percent in Switzerland and 14 percent in France. Overall, Muslims are among the most rejected social group.

  • Startbild Bildergalerie Studie Muslime in Europa ENG

    Muslims in Europe: Integrated or not?

    ‘Muslims in Europe – Integrated but not accepted’

    The information included in this picture gallery is from the Bertelsmann Foundation’s study titled ‘Muslims in Europe – Integrated but not accepted?’ Conclusions are based on a representative survey of more than 10,000 people in Germany, Austria, Switzerland, France and the UK. Muslim refugees who arrived in Europe after 2010 were not surveyed for the study.

    Author: Aasim Saleem


Religious neutrality?

NRW is the only state that still maintains publicly funded religious schools.

The court’s decision confirmed an NRW administrative court’s ruling that states are free to set up publicly funded schools administered by Germany’s two official Christian denominations: Catholics and Evangelicals. These schools are permitted to prefer students from their own religious faiths, but in practice they also give places to non-Christian children when they have space. On the other hand, Article 7 of Germany’s constitution, or Basic Law, states: “Parents and guardians shall have the right to decide whether children shall receive religious instruction.”

Constitutional court, Karlsruhe (picture-alliance/dpa/U. Deck)

The Constitutional Court decided not to take the case

Michael Wrase, a public law professor at the University of Hildesheim and research fellow at the Berlin Social Science Center, thought the court’s decision was problematic. “This is something you could really argue a lot about,” he said, before pointing out the legal paradox: “The state is allowed to set up such schools even though it is obligated to maintain religious neutrality.”

“It’s absurd to force a Muslim child, or an atheist child, to take Catholic religion lessons,” he added. “For me that’s a major invasion of religious freedom — and I think the court is overlooking that completely in this case.”

Problem of history …

Hans Michael Heinig, a professor of church law at the University of Göttingen and the director of the legal institute of the Evangelical Church in Germany, said he understood the logic of the court’s decision.

“The argument of the court was quite convincing,” he said. “As long as there are religious schools, these schools should be allowed to defend the religious profile of the school, and religious instruction is an important marker of this.”

“And, as long as the pupil could go to another school, to a nondenominational school, the court said it is okay that it is forced to join the instruction of a religious school,” he added. “I think the legal case is okay.”

The political question is another matter. The constitutional argument that state governments, rather than the federal government, have a right to determine the school system, was designed to guard against Nazi-era centralized interference, though Heinig argues that maintaining publicly funded religious schools is now outdated.

The other problem is historical: In 1949, when the Basic Law came into force, nearly everyone in Germany was a declared member of one or other of the two formal Christian churches, and paid their church tax to the state — so it seemed only natural that the state should fund Christian schools. “At that time it was not really a problem to have denominational schools,” said Heinig.

… and political will

Heinig said political cowardice was in part to blame for the problems associated with public religious education in NRW: The Social Democrats, who governed Germany’s most populous state for many years, “didn’t want to have a conflict with the Catholic church in the state, so they didn’t touch this school system.”

This is in contrast, oddly enough, with Bavaria, which has a much larger Catholic population and is governed by the conservative Christian Social Union, but has a much more secularized school system. In many areas, officials enforce a strict separation of religion and government in schools: Eight of Germany’s 16 states have banned female teachers from wearing headscarves as part of their religious expression.

“It’s really out-of-date,” Heinig said of the situation in NRW. “But it’s not a legal problem; it’s a political problem. The lawmaker has to change the system there. It’s quite easy: I think there should not be public religious schools for one religion. There should be a school system for all religions — with religious instruction for those that are religious, but no obligation to join this instruction.”

Article source: http://www.dw.com/en/court-muslim-boy-must-attend-nrw-school-s-catholic-service/a-41261543?maca=en-rss-en-ger-1023-xml-atom