Opinion: One year on, New Zealand struggles to make sense of mosque attacks

March 14, 2020

“How did this happen?”

On March 15, 2019, those four words were etched onto the lips of every New Zealander.

That afternoon, a lone gunman walked into two mosques in Christchurch, during Friday prayers — the busiest time of the week.

Many of the worshippers had their eyes closed and their backs to the gunman, as he began indiscriminately spraying bullets at them. Fifty-one were killed and dozens more injured.

The country’s innocence was shattered, and its identity was changed forever.

New Zealand, best known for rugby, wool, milk and hobbits, has always been proud of its independence.

The remote, rugged island nation — home to just 4 million people — is tucked away at the bottom of the world, far from the most dangerous hot spots.

In recent years, New Zealand has been shielded from the wave of nationalism and divisive, populist ideology that has swept across Europe and North America.

Read more: German far-right political scandal reflects rise of Europe’s populists

But the Christchurch terror attack proved that in the digital age, there is no safe haven from extremism.

The alleged gunman, who is yet to face trial, had outlined his xenophobic views in a manifesto that was published online before the attacks.

Attack exposed failures

Over the past 12 months, New Zealand has been forced to confront the systems, attitudes and social norms that allowed the attack to take place. This period of soul-searching has been uncomfortable and contentious — but also revealing.

For many years, New Zealand’s Muslim leaders had advised government agencies that their community was facing an increase in discrimination and threats, particularly from members of the alt-right.

In 2016, for example, a group of neo-Nazis delivered a box of pigs’ heads to the Al-Noor Mosque in Christchurch, chanting: “White power … Let’s get these f***ers out. Bring on the cull.”

Muslim leaders asked many state agencies for greater protection. They say that those requests fell on deaf ears. Instead, the agencies were fixated on weeding out potential terrorists from within the Muslim community itself.

Prime Minister Jacinda Adern hugs a mosque-goers at the Kilbirnie Mosque in Wellington

After the attack, Prime Minister Jacinda Adern met with mosquegoers at the Kilbirnie Mosque in Wellington

If security services were monitoring mosques, they should also have been exploring the dark recesses of popular social media platforms.

The Christchurch terror attack exposed the woeful failure of social media giants to identify and police the most inflammatory, dangerous — and, in some cases, criminal — activities that take place on their websites.

Read more: Germany and right-wing extremism: The new dimension of terror

These companies had created environments in which extremists could find each other, share information and become emboldened in their warped ideologies, before taking harmful actions in real life.

New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern launched the “Christchurch Call,” an agreement between states and online service providers to work together to eliminate hateful content.

Ardern’s leadership has received international acclaim. A striking photograph of the 37-year-old, who wore a hijab while meeting survivors of the terror attack, was printed around the world.

Racism overt and unspoken

But it was Ardern’s choice of words on the afternoon of the attack that resonated most deeply. Speaking about the refugee and migrant communities that had been affected, she said: “They are us.”

It was a statement of inclusion, tolerance and acceptance. These people were not simply visitors to New Zealand, Ardern said — they were Kiwis. They had put down roots on our soil, and they deserved to be safe.

As a person of color, and a second-generation Sri Lankan New Zealander, I appreciated that sentiment.

But over the past year, I have also been reminded that tensions around race and identity are deeply embedded in New Zealand society.

Jehan Casinader (Tom Hollow)

Jehan Casinader is a New Zealand broadcast journalist and covered the Christchurch terror attack and its aftermath

Racism exists here in many forms — both overt and unspoken; conscious and unconscious. Those of us who come from minority backgrounds have experienced it.

New Zealand is a former British colony, and has a shameful history of cultural oppression, beginning with the Crown’s treatment of the indigenous Maori people.

In 2020, New Zealand is a multicultural nation, but its heartland is built upon traditional values that often leave no room for other beliefs, ideas and ways of life.

For new arrivals to the country, life in “paradise” can be deeply isolating.

Challenges for all

As we mark the first anniversary of the Christchurch terror attack, powerful institutions will continue to face tough questions about their responsibility to crack down on extremism and hate speech.

But the real lesson to learn from Christchurch is much closer to home for every New Zealander: How can we stamp out prejudice in our schools, homes, workplaces and communities?

That challenge doesn’t only require leadership from state agencies and social media companies. It requires leadership from every citizen.

On March 15, 2019, we asked: “How did this happen?”

A year on, we ask: “How can we make sure that this never happens again?”

New Zealand holds memorial for mosque attack victims

Call for global action

At Friday’s memorial in a Christchurch park, New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern called on her country to “be the nation that discovers the cure” to the irrational hate and fear thought to be behind the March 15 mosque attacks. But she freely admitted that New Zealand itself was not immune to such “viruses.” She has won praise from around the world for the way she has dealt with the tragedy.

New Zealand holds memorial for mosque attack victims

A nation mourns

Thousands gathered for the memorial service at North Hagley Park. New Zealand has seen many outpourings of grief and condemnation after the attack, and its leaders have taken immediate action to tighten the country’s previously lax gun laws. Military-style semi-automatic and automatic firearms like those used in the March 15 attack are to be banned from April 11.

New Zealand holds memorial for mosque attack victims

Singing for peace and harmony

Among those performing at the Christchurch ceremony was Yusuf Islam, also known as Cat Stevens. Islam, himself a Muslim convert, performed his song “Peace Train.” “Our hearts go out to the families of those whose lives were snatched away in that evil carnage while they were worshipping at the mosque two weeks ago,” he said before his performance.

New Zealand holds memorial for mosque attack victims

National grief

The shootings by the suspected Australian gunman also left many people injured. Christchurch mayor Lianne Dalziel called the atrocity “an attack on us all.” But, she said, in the end a deed aimed at dividing people had “united us” instead. Services were also held in several other New Zealand cities.

New Zealand holds memorial for mosque attack victims

Speaking of forgiveness

The service in Christchurch was also attended by numerous dignitaries, including Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison. Among those who spoke was Farid Ahmed, the husband of Husna Ahmed, one of those who died in the attack in the Al Noor mosque. He told the crowd he had forgiven the shooter because of his beliefs. “I don’t want to have a heart that is boiling like a volcano,” Ahmed said.

Author: Timothy Jones