Rohnigya: Over one million reside in Bangladesh, but few feel at home

Five years after the latest and biggest mass exodus of Rohignya to Bangladesh, people in the camps say that the limbo they are living in is never ending. They don’t see much hope to get their normal lives back.

Today Hasina Begum asked her father to bring water from the community well because her husband is currently away from the refugee camp. This 23-year-old woman can’t do it herself because of her physical inability, that she is trying to conceal with her yellow dupatta — a shawl traditionally worn by women to cover the head and shoulders.

When asked the reason for her disability, with tears Hasina recalled a day five years back.

“They (Myanmar military) hit me with a rod. I was drenched with blood and they thought I was dead. So they left me there,” Begum told DW.

Even five years later she still has pain in her head and feet.

Hasina was a victim of a brutal crackdown by the Myanmar military in 2017. The Myanmar military began a sweeping campaign of massacres, rape, and arson in northern Rakhine State on August 25, 2017, following attacks on the border posts by some Rohingya militants.

The campaign killed thousands of Rohingya, according to many international organizations, including Doctors Without Borders. At the time of the exodus, the United Nations say more than 745,000 people fled to neighboring Bangladesh. That figure now stands at over a million. Begum and her family now live in a refugee camp.

• The challenges of reporting on migrants and refugees in South Asia

  “Media, Information, and Participation in Displacement and Migration Settings – How Free is the Media?”

  There are 2.5 million to 50 million refugees and internally displaced people in South Asia. Earlier this year, DW Akademie, the Calcutta Research Group and the Center for International Media Assistance met with journalists, academics and rights activists – all stakeholders there – to discuss the issue of reporting in displacement settings.

• The challenges of reporting on migrants and refugees in South Asia

  Babita Basnet, newspaper editor, Nepal

  Babita Basnet, an editor at a weekly newspaper in Nepal, has observed policies that ignore women and their critical need for reliable information. She says that many women in Nepal are obligated to migrate abroad for economic reasons but that poverty and cultural stigmas trail them. Media, she believes, can raise awareness and inform would-be migrants or displaced persons.

• The challenges of reporting on migrants and refugees in South Asia

  Reyaz Mohammed, journalism professor, India

  Scarce information or disinformation on displacement remains a problem, says Mohammad Reyaz, an assistant journalism professor at Aliah University, India. Muslims, he notes, who migrate within India for economic reasons or because they have been displaced due to natural disasters, are often falsely accused of being illegally in the country. The media can, and should, better explain their stories.

• The challenges of reporting on migrants and refugees in South Asia

  Zia Ur-Rehman, New York Times contributor, Pakistan

  A New York Times contributor for South Asia, Zia Ur-Rehman has observed that Pakistani media shy away from reporting on migration and displacement. Therefore most Pakistanis themselves have a limited understanding of the crisis in their country which hosts several million Afghan refugees. Stories, he says, often portray displaced persons as criminals and responsible for their own predicament.

• The challenges of reporting on migrants and refugees in South Asia

  Iqbal Khattak, journalist, Pakistan

  Iqbal Khattak founded Freedom Network, a media watchdog group, in 2013. He says that in Pakistan, mass displacement and refugee camps have been a crisis for nearly half a century, starting with the Soviet Union’s invasion of Afghanistan. For him, it is the media’s job to draw attention to suffering and to investigate how the host country assists and integrates displaced people and migrants.

• The challenges of reporting on migrants and refugees in South Asia

  Khushal Asefi, Afghan journalist, Germany

  In nearly 20 years working in Afghan media, including as Ariana TV’s managing director, Khushal Asefi’s work focused on his country’s turbulence both during and after Taliban rule. Asefi fled Afghanistan in August 2021, and his resettlement in Germany has personalized migration’s hardships. He observes that refugees often resist sharing their stories with the media, fearing arrest or deportation.

• The challenges of reporting on migrants and refugees in South Asia

  Sulochana Ramiah Mohan, editor, Sri Lanka

  Sulochana Ramiah Mohan is Ceylon Today’s deputy editor in Sri Lanka, as well as a contributor to Asahi Shimbun in Japan. She reports on international relations, migration and displacement, the climate, and social justice, among other topics. She notes that statistics on internal displacement in Sri Lanka are unreliable, though economic and political crises have forced many residents to flee.

• The challenges of reporting on migrants and refugees in South Asia

  Dr. Lopita Nath, professor, United States

  Dr. Lopita Nath chairs the History Department and directs the Asian Studies Program at the University of the Incarnate Word in San Antonio, Texas. Nath focuses on migration in Asia, refugees, and human rights and serves on the Catholic Charities Refugee Advisory Board. Her current research is on Bhutanese refugee resettlement in the United States.

Life in the Bangladeshi camps

Begum lives with her husband and child in a tiny two room house in the Balukhali camp, which is the largest refugee camp in the world, hosting some 600,000 refugees, according to figures collated by a number of human rights bodies, such as the Refugee Council USA.

“My husband has no work. He goes to Tabligh (a religious group)” for food and other aid, Begum told DW. 

Most of the people are also unemployed, like Enayetullah, 44, the father of Begum. He returns with a pot of water.

“We had huge farmlands. I used to cultivate them. We had cattle, a house and a lot of possessions. We left them all behind,” Ullah recalls.

Ullah says when he fled from Myanmar, he fled with his life. He did not think of his possessions. But now after five years, he misses his home, and his lands.

Seeking work, without prospects

Like Ullah, many people in the camps want to work and rebuild their lives.

“We can’t go out of the camps. Sometimes we get a call to work. But that is rare,” says 33-year-old Mohammad Shafi.

The Rohingya are also struggling with limited education opportunities.

Mohammad Riaz is a 10th grade student. This will be his last year of education inside the camps.

“After this year I will have no opportunity to study further, but I want higher education,” Riaz told DW.

Rohingya children can obtain some education in the refugee camps, but many want more

Searching for more opportunities, many Rohingya try to flee the camps to and leave Bangladesh. 

On the eve of the anniversary of the 2017 exodus, Acting Asia Director at Human Rights Watch Elaine Pearson released a statement saying: “Donors should support Rohingya refugees to study and work freely and safely so they can build independent and self-reliant futures.”

UN’s Bachelet visits Bangladesh but life remains in limbo

UN Human Rights Commissioner Michelle Bachelet recently visited the Rohingya refugees in Bangladesh, with community representatives telling her they want to build a better life.

“One day I want to go home, but I don’t know when I can,” Ullah told DW.

More than a million Rohingya currently reside in Bangladesh, but few people would call it home.

The life of the Rohingya remains in limbo within the camps, with no end in sight to their current plight.

“When I remember my homeland, my heart burns. I want to go back,” Tasmida Begum told DW. “But only if they give us peace, and give our possessions back.”

Tasmida Begum is afraid that the military might attack again if she goes back. She lost a brother and a brother-in-law in 2017.

Aung Kyaw Moe, an advisor to the National Unity Government of Myanmar, run by the Suu Kyi led NLD party, thinks that the repatriation has not been possible untill now because of a lack of interest from the Myanmar government.

“It is not happening because of the lack of political will from the Myanmar side,” Moe told DW. He is the first Rohingya to hold a position in a Myanmar government. “They don’t want them to go back.”

The repatriation talks are in place among Myanmar, Bangladesh and different bodies of the United Nations. A joint task force is in place to finalize the list of Rohingya people to be repatriated.

“We have already given them a list of 830,000 Rohingya. They have accepted that,” Shamsud Douza, an Additional Refugee, Relief and Repatriation Commissioner told DW. “We are providing them with humanitarian aid but at some point they have to leave.”

Bangladesh is hopeful of sending back the Rohingya people to Myanmar. Recently, the country’s foreign minister told the press that the start of repatriation might be possible by the end of 2022. 

“We are hopeful we can start the repatriation by the end of the year. We are trying to do it for our own interest because they are becoming a burden for us,” he told reporters on August 21.

However, after two prior repatriation attempts failed, Moe thinks the list is just a method of delaying the process. “Myanmar has the list. They know very well who have fled,” he told DW. “If they really want to initiate the repatriation process they would have given a list to Bangladesh, find them and send them back.”

Will there be justice?

Five years on, nobody has been held accountable for the brutality that happened in Myanmar. Gambia has launched a genocide case about the issue before the International Court of Justice (ICJ). The case is being heard. The Myanmar government had filed an appeal, but this has since been rejected. 

Rights organizations demand that the UN Security Council end its current inaction and urgently negotiate a resolution to institute a global arms embargo on Myanmar. Human Rights Watch said that they should refer the situation to the International Criminal Court, and impose targeted sanctions on the junta and military-owned conglomerates.

But a UN action on this scale might be vetoed by China and Russia.

“China has always been a problem for the Rohingya. We have to find innovative way to deal with the blockages created by China and Russia particularly in the Security Council and other UN bodies,” Moe told DW.

Meanwhile, Hasina said she has no idea what justice should look like. To her, getting back to a normal life is a long way off, with the mental and physical wounds leaving more than just the visible scars on her body.

“I don’t know what will happen next. I don’t see a future here or anywhere,” she told DW.

Edited by: John Silk

Article source: https://www.dw.com/en/rohnigya-over-one-million-reside-in-bangladesh-but-few-feel-at-home/a-62914236?maca=en-rss-en-all-1573-rdf